• About
  • Contact
  • Write For Us
No Result
View All Result
Donate
The Asian Cut
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Essays
  • Director Retrospectives
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Essays
  • Director Retrospectives
No Result
View All Result
The Asian Cut
No Result
View All Result

WFF 2022: ‘Shallots & Garlic/Bawang Merah Bawang Putih’ Dishes Out A Woman’s Universal Truth

Rachel Ho by Rachel Ho
December 20, 2022
in Review
0
Shallots and Garlic, Bawang Merah Bawang Putih.

Photo Courtesy of the Whistler Film Festival

⭐⭐⭐⭐

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Shallots & Garlic is the latest short film by Indonesian director Andrea Nirmala Widjajanto. Taking a body horror lens to the terrors of eating disorders, Widjajanto taps into the grip an unhealthy relationship with food can have on one’s soul.

Ni Gusti Ayu Nanditha stars as the seemingly perfect older sister and daughter. When the family comes together to celebrate her grandparents’ anniversary, the cracks between her and her sister start to appear. As the family praises the elder child for her accomplishments and beauty, it becomes clear that her little sister, played by Rai Putriansyah, has eaten next to nothing. We later see the two sisters in the washroom, the younger rising from the floor and the elder complaining about the smell. Years of toilet-humoured shows and movies will cause audiences to mistake this for one thing, but as the younger rinses her mouth, it’s clear what they’re referring to.

The entire short is played as a traditional horror film. The fish-eyed close ups evoke stress and anxiety while the relentless score brings our shoulders up to our ears, freezing them for the entirety of the 18 minute runtime.

RelatedStories

Anghlong Konyak and Sobino Rengma as Anghbah and his son Amao in the film Angh by Theja Rio.

TIFF 2026: ‘Angh’ Is a Beautiful Elegy for Nagaland’s Tribal History 

A still form the documentary Ba's Book of a man in a field walking towards two workers lifting a bale of hay

TIFF 2026: ‘Ba’s Book’ Turns a Father’s Memories Into a Family Affair

The most harrowing moment of the film comes after the younger sister cleans up any residual vomit from her mouth. When their mother walks in, there is a faint ‘gotcha’-tension felt in the frame. It’s another bait and switch, though. Rather than admonish her daughter, she is critical of how this was done. It’s then we see the bubbling scars of all the women who have carried this burden and perpetuated this behaviour.

Shallots & Garlic sends a powerful message through impressive filmmaking. Widjajanto shows some incredible promise and I’m excited to see what she does next.

Now Streaming On

JustWatch

The Review

Tags: Andrea Nirmala WidjajantoBawang Merah Bawang PutihIndonesiaShallots & GarlicShort FilmWhistler Film Festival
ShareTweet
Rachel Ho

Rachel Ho

Rachel Ho is a freelance film critic, writer and edtor. Currently, she is the film editor at Exclaim! Magazine and has contributed to a variety of publications such as, The Globe and Mail, CBC Arts, POV Magazine, Slash Film, eliteGen Magazine and others. In 2021, Rachel received the Toronto Film Critic's Emerging Critic Award and has been a voter for the Golden Globe Awards since 2022.

Recommended For You

Photo still from The Draft!
Review

Reel Asian 2024: ‘The Draft!’ Is a Bold and Chaotic Meta Horror-Comedy

Photo still from Monisme, directed by Riar Rizaldi.
Review

Riar Rizaldi’s Cryptic Indonesian Docufiction ‘Monisme’ Is a Fascinating Avant-Garde Take on the Conceptual Film

Film still from Mould
Review

Reel Asian 2024: ‘Mould’ Struggles to Sustain Its Tension

Abimana Aryasatya as Sancaka wearing a red and black superhero costume in Gundala
Review

‘Gundala’ Fails to Replicate the MCU’s Early Success

A Passage Beyond Fortune
Review

‘A Passage Beyond Fortune’ Shows One Chinese Family’s History in Canada

A man playing an accordion in the short film Bita Joon.
Review

‘Bita Joon’ Is a Complex Lesson That Reveals Life’s Hidden Sentimentalities

Next Post
Andrew Phung as Andrew and Rakhee Morzaria as Camillefor CBC's Run the Burbs.

Andrew Phung and Rakhee Morzaria are Shaking Off the Criticism of Inauthenticity on 'Run The Burbs'

Popular Stories

Consonance by Brian Jiang

The Asian Cut’s #ReelAsian26 Festival Favourites

4 years ago
Director Roshan Sethi, Karan Soni as Naveen Gavaskar behind the scenes of A Nice Indian Boy

Roshan Sethi and Karan Soni on ‘A Nice Indian Boy’: “I wanted it to feel true more than anything else”

1 year ago
Photo still from the short film Boat People, directed by Thao Lam and Kjell Boersma.

Canadian Film Fest 2024: Six Shorts

3 years ago
Ha Seong-guk as Inguk sitting on the floor playing a keyboard across from Isabelle Huppert as Iris sitting on a bed in the movie A Traveler's Needs.

‘A Traveler’s Needs’ Is a Perfectly Offbeat Film from Hong Sang-soo

Quen Wong standing on a bridge holding an apple in the documentary Some Women.

Reel Asian 2022: ‘Some Women’ Is a Masterful Exploration of Womanhood

  • About
  • Contact
  • Write For Us

Copyright © The Asian Cut 2026. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Essays
  • Director Retrospectives
  • Write For Us
  • Contact

Copyright © The Asian Cut 2026. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use